Your website looks great but generates zero leads? Discover the 10 critical mistakes killing your conversions and learn step-by-step fixes. Includes real examples, priority checklists, and actionable strategies to turn your website into a lead-generating machine.
Last month, I had a conversation with David, a local contractor who'd spent $8,000 on a new website six months ago. "It looks great," he told me. "But I've gotten maybe three inquiries total. My old website from 2015 was getting more leads than this one. What am I doing wrong?"
When I analyzed his website, I found the problem immediately: his site was beautiful but broken. It had all the visual polish but none of the functional elements that actually convert visitors into leads. David's story isn't unique—I see this exact scenario with 60% of the business websites I audit.
The harsh truth? Having a website doesn't automatically mean you'll get leads. In 2025, your website needs to do more than just exist—it needs to actively guide visitors toward taking action. If your website isn't generating leads, it's almost certainly making one (or more) of these 10 critical mistakes.
In this comprehensive guide, I'll show you exactly what's wrong with your website and how to fix it. You'll learn the specific mistakes killing your conversions, real examples from businesses like yours, and actionable fixes you can implement today—even if you're not technical.
After auditing hundreds of business websites, I've identified the 10 mistakes that appear most frequently. These aren't minor issues—each one can reduce your lead generation by 20-50%. Fix them, and you'll see immediate improvements in your conversion rate.
The Problem: Your website looks great, but visitors don't know what to do next. There's no obvious button, form, or action that guides them toward becoming a lead.
Why It Matters: Without a clear CTA, visitors will browse your site and leave. They might be interested, but you're not telling them how to take the next step. 73% of websites fail to have a clear CTA above the fold—meaning visitors see it without scrolling.
Real Example:
A law firm had a beautiful homepage with their practice areas, attorney bios, and case results. But there was no "Schedule a Consultation" button visible. After adding a prominent CTA button, their consultation requests increased by 340% in 30 days.
How to Fix It:
Need help optimizing your CTAs? Our website design services include conversion-focused CTA placement and testing.
The Problem: Visitors land on your homepage and can't immediately understand what you do, who you help, or why they should choose you. Your value proposition is buried in paragraphs of text or doesn't exist at all.
Why It Matters: You have 8 seconds to capture a visitor's attention. If they can't understand your value in that time, they'll leave. Generic statements like "We provide quality service" don't differentiate you from competitors.
Real Example:
A marketing agency's homepage said: "We help businesses grow." After changing it to "We help local restaurants get 3x more reservations through Google Maps optimization," their qualified leads increased by 180%.
How to Fix It:
Struggling to craft your value proposition? Our branding strategy services help you identify and communicate what makes your business unique.
The Problem: Your website looks great on desktop but is broken, slow, or hard to use on mobile devices. Forms are difficult to fill out, buttons are too small, or text is unreadable.
Why It Matters: 62% of website traffic comes from mobile devices. If your mobile experience is poor, you're losing more than half of your potential leads. Google also penalizes mobile-unfriendly sites in search rankings.
Real Example:
A dental practice's contact form required 12 fields and was nearly impossible to complete on mobile. After simplifying to 4 fields and optimizing for mobile, form submissions increased by 250%.
How to Fix It:
Need mobile optimization? Our website design services include mobile-first responsive design that converts on all devices.
The Problem: Your website takes 8-15 seconds to load. Visitors get frustrated and leave before your content even appears. Every second of delay reduces conversions by 7%.
Why It Matters: 53% of mobile visitors abandon sites that take longer than 3 seconds to load. Slow sites also rank lower in Google search results, meaning fewer visitors even find your site.
Real Example:
An e-commerce site was loading in 12 seconds. After optimizing images, enabling caching, and upgrading hosting, load time dropped to 2.3 seconds. Sales increased by 47% in the first month.
How to Fix It:
Need speed optimization? Our website maintenance services include performance optimization and speed improvements.
The Problem: Visitors don't know if they can trust you. There are no testimonials, reviews, case studies, certifications, or proof that you deliver results.
Why It Matters: 88% of consumers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations. Without social proof, visitors have no reason to believe you're credible or that you'll deliver on your promises.
Real Example:
A consulting firm added client testimonials, case study results, and industry certifications to their homepage. Conversion rate increased from 1.2% to 4.1%—a 240% improvement.
How to Fix It:
Need help getting reviews? Check out our guide on how to get more Google reviews, or use our digital marketing services to build your online reputation.
The Problem: Your contact form asks for 15+ fields including unnecessary information. Visitors get overwhelmed and abandon the form before submitting.
Why It Matters: Every additional form field reduces completion rate by 11%. Asking for too much information upfront creates friction and makes visitors question whether it's worth their time.
Real Example:
A home services company reduced their form from 12 fields to 4 (name, phone, email, service needed). Form submissions increased by 180%, and they still got all the information they needed to qualify leads.
How to Fix It:
Need form optimization? Our website design services include conversion-optimized form design and A/B testing.
The Problem: Your website isn't showing up in Google search results for keywords your potential customers are searching. You're invisible to people actively looking for your services.
Why It Matters: 68% of online experiences start with a search engine. If you're not ranking, you're missing the majority of potential customers. Organic search traffic is also free and high-quality compared to paid ads.
Real Example:
A local HVAC company optimized their site for "emergency HVAC repair [city]" and related keywords. Within 4 months, they went from zero organic traffic to 450+ monthly visitors, resulting in 12-15 new service calls per month.
How to Fix It:
Need SEO help? Our SEO services help you rank higher in Google and attract qualified organic traffic. Learn more about why SEO is important for business success.
The Problem: Visitors can't find your pricing, service packages, or what's included. They have to contact you just to understand what you offer and how much it costs.
Why It Matters: 80% of B2B buyers want pricing information before contacting a vendor. Hiding pricing creates friction and makes visitors question transparency. Many will leave to find a competitor who's more upfront.
Real Example:
A web design agency added a "Pricing" page with three clear packages and starting prices. Even though they required a consultation for exact quotes, inquiries increased by 220% because visitors understood the investment range upfront.
How to Fix It:
Need help structuring your services? Our website design services include service page optimization and clear pricing presentation.
The Problem: Your website content is generic, vague, or copied from competitors. It doesn't speak to your specific audience or address their unique problems and questions.
Why It Matters: Generic content doesn't differentiate you from competitors or build trust. Visitors can't tell why they should choose you over someone else. Content that addresses specific customer pain points converts 6x better than generic marketing copy.
Real Example:
A financial advisor replaced generic "wealth management" copy with specific content addressing "retirement planning for small business owners." Qualified leads increased by 150% because the content spoke directly to their target audience's needs.
How to Fix It:
Need content strategy? Our digital marketing services include content creation and strategy that converts visitors into leads.
The Problem: Even when visitors are interested, you're not capturing their information or following up. There's no email list signup, no lead magnet, and no automated follow-up sequence.
Why It Matters: 96% of website visitors aren't ready to buy on their first visit. If you're not capturing their information, you're losing 96% of your potential leads. Most sales require 5-7 touchpoints before conversion.
Real Example:
A marketing agency added a free "Local SEO Checklist" download with email capture. They captured 45 email addresses in the first month, and 12 of those became paying clients within 90 days—a 27% conversion rate from email list to customer.
How to Fix It:
Need lead generation help? Our digital marketing services include email marketing, lead magnets, and automated follow-up systems that convert visitors into customers.
Before you start fixing everything, it's important to identify which specific mistakes are hurting your website. Here's a systematic approach to diagnose your problems:
Fix issues in this order for maximum impact:
Don't try to fix everything at once. Focus on these high-impact changes first, then move to the next set. Here's your priority action plan:
After implementing fixes, you need to track whether they're actually improving your lead generation. Here are the key metrics to monitor:
📊 Expected Timeline for Results:
Remember: Not all fixes show immediate results. SEO and content improvements take 2-4 months to fully impact rankings and traffic. But CTA, form, and trust signal improvements should show results within days.
It depends on which fixes you implement. CTA improvements, form simplification, and trust signals typically show results within 1-2 weeks. SEO improvements and content optimization take 2-4 months to fully impact rankings and traffic. Speed optimizations show immediate improvements in user experience and can boost conversions within days.
You should prioritize based on impact. Start with the critical issues: no CTA, slow speed, poor mobile experience, and no trust signals. These four fixes alone can increase your conversion rate by 50-100%. Then move to high-priority items like weak value proposition and poor SEO. You don't need to fix everything at once—focus on the biggest impact first.
Many fixes can be done yourself with basic website knowledge: adding CTAs, simplifying forms, adding testimonials, optimizing content. However, technical issues like speed optimization, SEO implementation, and mobile responsiveness often require developer expertise. Many businesses use a hybrid approach: handle content and design fixes themselves, and hire professionals for technical optimization.
If you've fixed the major issues and still aren't getting leads, the problem might be traffic, not conversion. You may need to focus on driving more qualified visitors to your site through SEO, paid advertising, or content marketing. It's also possible your target audience or value proposition needs refinement. Consider getting a professional website audit to identify remaining issues.
Costs vary widely. Basic fixes (CTAs, forms, content) can be done for free or low cost if you do them yourself. Professional website optimization typically costs $1,500-$5,000 for a complete overhaul. Ongoing SEO and content marketing range from $500-$3,000/month depending on scope. Many businesses see ROI within 3-6 months as leads increase.
At Coko Agency, we specialize in turning underperforming websites into lead-generating machines. We've helped hundreds of businesses identify and fix the exact mistakes outlined in this guide, resulting in 2-5x more leads and significant revenue growth.
Our comprehensive website optimization services include everything from conversion rate optimization and SEO to mobile optimization and content strategy. We don't just fix problems—we build websites that actively work to generate leads and grow your business.
Our website optimization and lead generation services include:
Get your free website audit and lead generation plan →
We'll analyze your website, identify the specific mistakes hurting your lead generation, and provide a detailed action plan to fix them. No commitments—just expert guidance to help you turn your website into a lead-generating machine.
Learn how to hire the right web designer or agency for your business. Complete guide covering freelancer vs. agency, essential questions to ask, portfolio evaluation, red flags to avoid, and how to ensure your website generates leads and sales.
Learn how to make your website accessible and ADA compliant in 2025. Complete guide covering WCAG 2.1 standards, legal requirements, step-by-step checklists, and business benefits. Avoid lawsuits and reach 26% more customers with an accessible website.
Confused about which website platform to choose? Compare Wix, Squarespace, WordPress, Shopify, and custom development. Get real costs, pros and cons, and a decision framework to choose the right platform for your business type, budget, and needs.